Sapir Team Real Estate
WOW

Manhattan August Market Report

  • Sapir Team
  • September 14, 2023

Watch this content HERE.

 

It’s September, and with it, some seasonal winds of change for Manhattan’s real estate market. August was slower, as expected, and so was the first half of September, a relatively quiet time in NYC’s real estate market. What’s ahead?  Keep reading.

Manhattan supply chart from 2008 to September 2023, ending at 6,078 listings.

Supply continued to drop this August to the low six thousand, a 3.5% or so drop both from last month and last year.

Manhattan monthly new supply chart: 787 in August 2023, below the historical average of 952.

787 new listings came to market in August, a 19.5% decline from the previous month. This decrease in available inventory has also affected activity, with monthly contract activity falling by 7% from July.

Chart comparing Manhattan monthly contract activity with historical averages; August 2023 shows 799 contracts versus 841.

We do expect supply to rise in the next week or so, as sellers return from their summers away and a new listing wave hits the market. The number of signed contracts is also expected to rise in October, as a result of some new business being done over the busier fall season.

Manhattan pending sales chart from 2008 to August 2023, ending at 2,658.

Pending sales are up by close to 60% year to date, and by 6% from last month, to 2,775. We expect this number to start declining significantly over the next 2-3 weeks as deals continue to close. When supply drops it puts pressure on the market pulse, making it rise.

Manhattan Market Pulse chart showing 2008–2023 trends across buyer, neutral, and seller markets.

It is worth remembering, however, that both the pending sales and market pulse are in a 6-month window, not the most current data. Market Pulse is at 0.44 with a 10% increase from last month, reflecting those pending sales that are not out yet. UrbanDigs launched a new metric called liquid pace, that uses liquidity as a more up-to-date measure. When we look at it now, the market pulse remains in the middle with no significant rise, indicating a more neutral market.

Line chart comparing Liquid Pulse and its 30-day moving average from January 2019 to July 2023.

With fewer listings on the market, prices remain high with the median sales price hovering close to one million-two, and more than 20% increase in the monthly number of sales closing above-asking price.

Manhattan median sale price chart from 2008 to August 2023, ending at $1,177,500.

 

 

Sales over asking price in Q2: 11.7%, with 20.4% prior month and -38.8% prior year.

 

 

The median discount also remains at 4% with no change from last month. Sellers are locked into their low interest-rates, contributing further to the pressure on inventory and driving the prices up. Supply is not keeping up with demand.

Bar chart of Manhattan listing discounts, 2008–2023; August 2023 is 4.1%, up 57.7% year over year.

When we look at the pace of liquidity, a 30-day moving window of signed contracts, we also see a decline in demand, and this is expected to last for the next 3 weeks or so.  

Manhattan liquidity pace chart showing historical values and the latest reading of 762.

Manhattan’s rental market may be starting to even out. The median rent dropped slightly from last month and is now at $4,303, a 4.2% decrease. With new legislation regarding short-term rentals and rezoning for office-to-residential buildings, we may see more units become available for long-term renters in the upcoming years.


Chart comparing Manhattan median and average rents and rented listings in August 2021 and 2022.

So, what awaits our market?

I predict a rise in available inventory, more activity in the market, and more contracts signed toward October-November. Rents will remain high but will most likely not go higher than they are, and sale prices will not drop by much, as long as sellers continue to hold on to their low rates and refuse to go on the market. Negotiability, as a result, will remain limited. Sellers listing their units will see more activity; the time to transact is NOW.